Punishment for not telling

Through all the troubled learning my slave had last month. I allowed that the emotions where punishment enough for the trouble the slave brought on himself. That being said I had to punish the slave for the lie of not tell Master when he willfully broke with protocol. It took over two weeks for it to wear on slaves heart enough to tell his master. After slave told me of the break in protocol and the reason it happened I had no problem with it. I did however have issue with the lies. This was the second time slave has lied in this manner. A beating was the punishment for the first time and it was to be again. This beating was to be harder and longer. In the end I warmed slaves ass with fifty swats on each cheek with the paddle. Then we talked and made slave understand what he was being punished for. After talking I gave slave the choice take this and his emotions to bed and suffer or more swats to clear his conscience he chose swats. Second choice another hundred with the paddle or fifty with slave least favorite tool a riding crop. Slave chose the crop. The pix are after the punishment. Slave would not stay still so there are swats on his back to remind him to stay still.